Debt Collection: What Collectors Can’t Do (Scripts Inside)

Table of Contents

If a collector is blowing up your phone, sending scary letters, or texting you at odd hours, you’re not powerless. You have clear rights. Collectors must follow strict rules. When they don’t, you can push back and often get real results.

This guide breaks down what collectors can’t do, what they must do, and exactly how to respond. You’ll get simple scripts, letter templates, and step-by-step actions that work in the real world.

(Quick note: laws vary by country and state. This article is educational, not legal advice. If you’re facing a lawsuit or urgent situation, talk to a consumer attorney or a qualified advisor in your area.)

The quick answer

• Collectors can’t harass you, lie to you, or threaten arrest.

• They can’t call you before early morning or late at night (your local law sets the exact times).

• They can’t discuss your debt with friends, family, or your boss.

• They must tell you details about the debt and who they are.

• You can demand that they stop contacting you in writing.

• You can dispute the debt and force them to verify it.

• Old debts may be past the time limit to sue (called the statute of limitations).

• If you’re sued, don’t ignore it. Respond by the deadline and get help.

Your core rights (and what collectors can’t do)

1) No harassment, bullying, or abuse

Harassment is illegal. That includes:

• Repeated, back-to-back calls meant to annoy.

• Swearing, insults, or name-calling.

• Threats of violence or harm.

• Posting about your debt on social media or telling others.

You don’t have to “tough it out.” Keep a call log. If you spot a pattern, you have leverage.

2) No lies or tricks

Collectors can’t lie about:

• The amount you owe.

• Who they are (e.g., pretending to be police, a lawyer, or the government).

• What will happen if you don’t pay (e.g., arrest, immediate wage garnishment, seizure of property without a court judgment)?

They also can’t send documents that look like court papers when they aren’t, or threaten actions they don’t intend to take.

3) No sharing your debt with others

Collectors can’t tell your family, roommates, neighbors, or boss that you owe money. They can call a third party only to get your contact information, and they can’t say it’s about a debt. If they keep contacting your employer or relatives, that’s a violation.

4) No calls at inconvenient times or places

Most laws restrict calls at odd hours (for example, very early morning or late night). They also must stop calling you at work if you tell them you’re not allowed to take calls there. Use a simple line like, “My employer does not allow personal calls. Do not contact me at work.”

5) They must tell you who they are and what the debt is

Within a short period after first contact, you should receive details commonly called a “validation notice.” It should include:

• The amount of the debt.

• The name of the current creditor.

• How to dispute the debt in writing.

• Your deadline to dispute.

If you don’t get this, ask for it in writing (template below). Until they provide it, you’re not required to pay a cent.

6) You can dispute the debt—on the spot or in writing

If something doesn’t look right (wrong amount, wrong person, a debt that was already paid), dispute it. When you dispute in writing within the deadline, the collector must pause collection until they provide verification.

7) No extra fees that aren’t allowed

Collectors can’t pile on interest, fees, or charges unless your original agreement or local law allows it. Always ask for a detailed accounting if the number has changed.

8) If you have a lawyer, they must talk to your lawyer

Once a collector knows you’re represented, they should contact your lawyer, not you. If they keep contacting you, that’s not okay.

9) Digital messages and social media have rules, too

Text, email, and DM outreach must follow the same laws as phone calls and letters. They can’t pressure you, tag you publicly, or mislead you. You can tell them to stop.

10) Old debts may be past the time limit to sue

Every region has a time limit to file a lawsuit on a debt, known as the statute of limitations. Once the limit passes, collectors can ask you to pay, but they usually can’t win a lawsuit. Warning: In some places, making a small payment or a written promise to pay can restart the clock. Know your local rules before paying or acknowledging an old debt.

How to stop calls (PAA)

You have three powerful tools:

1. Tell them to stop calling you, especially at work or by phone.

2. Send a cease-contact letter.

3. Force verification by disputing the debt in writing.

Step-by-step plan

1. Answer once, take control. Get the caller’s name, company, phone number, and mailing address. Ask for the written validation notice if you don’t already have it.

2. Say your boundary. If calls are the issue, say: “Do not call me by phone. Communicate only by mail (or email).”

3. Follow up in writing. Send a short letter or email that:

   • States you’re requesting no further contact by phone.

   • Disputes the debt if it’s wrong or unclear.

   • Requests verification.

4. Save everything. Keep call logs, voicemails, texts, envelopes, and screenshots.

5. Filter and block. Use your phone’s block list. Save voicemails. Don’t delete anything.

Scripts you can use (phone)

If you pick up and want them to stop calling:

“I’m not discussing this by phone. Send me everything in writing. Do not call me again. If you continue calling, I will document it.”

At work:

“My employer prohibits these calls. Don’t contact me at work again.”

If they won’t say who they are:

“Identify yourself and your company, or this call is over.”

If the debt sounds wrong:

“I dispute this debt. Send me verification in writing.”

If they get aggressive:

“Stop. Your tone is abusive. I will end this call now.”

Cease-contact letter (template)

[Your Name]  
[Your Address]  
[City, State/Province, Postal Code]  
[Email] [Phone]

[Date]

[Collector’s Name]  
[Company]  
[Address]

Re: Cease Contact & Validation Request

I request that you stop contacting me by phone, text, or social media. Communicate only in writing to the address above.

I dispute this debt. Please provide validation, including the name of the original creditor, the amount, and a detailed accounting.

If you believe I owe this debt, include documentation supporting your claim.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

Send it by a trackable method if you can, and keep a copy.

Can they sue me? (PAA)

Short answer: Yes, a collector can sue, but there are rules. Whether they’ll win depends on proof, timing, and your response.

What to know about lawsuits

• Don’t ignore court papers. If you’re served, respond by the deadline listed in the paperwork. If you don’t, the collector can get a default judgment, basically an automatic win.

• They must prove the case. The collector has to show you owe the debt, that they’re allowed to collect it, and the correct amount. If the debt was sold multiple times, the paperwork often gets messy.

• Time limits matter. If the statute of limitations expired, you can raise that as a defense.

• Settlements are common. Even after you’re sued, you can negotiate, but get any deal in writing before paying.

• Judgments carry weight. With a judgment, a collector may ask the court for tools like wage garnishment or bank levies (this depends on local law and exemptions).

• If they break the rules, you may have claims too. Keep records of violations. In some places, you can counter-sue or recover damages and attorney’s fees.

If you’re served, take a breath, read the papers carefully, mark the response date, and get advice from a consumer lawyer or legal aid in your area.

What collectors can do (so you’re not surprised)

• Contact you by phone, letter, text, email, or private social messages during lawful hours.

• Report to credit bureaus (depending on your country’s system and timelines).

• Negotiate for a payment plan or settlement.

• Sell or transfer the debt to another collector.

• Sue you within the legal time limit, with evidence.

• Ask for your employer or bank details, but you don’t have to share sensitive info over the phone. Keep it minimal and only after you see everything in writing.

Scripts that work (save these)

If you want everything in writing

“Send all future communication in writing to my mailing address. I won’t discuss this by phone.”

If you’re not sure it’s your debt

“I dispute this debt and request validation, including the original creditor and a breakdown of the amount. Pause collection until you provide it.”

If the amount looks inflated

“Provide an itemized statement of principal, interest, fees, and payments. I won’t consider payment until I review documentation.”

If they call your workplace

“My employer prohibits personal collection calls. Do not contact me at work again.”

If you feel pressured

“I don’t agree to anything today. Send the terms in writing. I’ll review and respond.”

If you’re ready to negotiate

“If documentation confirms the debt, I’m open to resolving it. I can offer [X% lump sum] in exchange for a written agreement that the account will be reported as ‘paid’ and the balance forgiven.”

(Tip: Never give card or bank access before you have a signed agreement. If possible, pay with a method that doesn’t give the collector ongoing control.)

If you owe the debt: smart ways to resolve it

1) Verify first, pay second

Even if you believe the debt is yours, ask for verification. Mistakes happen—wrong balance, duplicate accounts, fees that don’t belong. You can’t undo pay.

2) Decide your strategy

• Lump-sum settlement: If you can pay a chunk, you might settle for less than the full amount. Get the deal in writing before paying.

• Payment plan: If cash is tight, propose an affordable plan. Keep it realistic—missed payments can void deals.

• Hardship pause: If you’re going through a crisis, ask for a temporary hold or reduced payments.

3) Get everything in writing

A real settlement letter should include:

• The account number and the creditor.

• The settlement amount and due date(s).

• How the account will be reported after payment.

• A statement that the remaining balance will be forgiven and not sold.

• Who to contact if there’s an issue.

4) Protect your accounts

Avoid giving a collector direct access to your everyday bank account. Use a separate account or payment method. Don’t send post-dated checks unless you understand the risks.

5) Think about your bigger picture

If you have multiple debts, talk to a reputable nonprofit credit counselor. They can help you triage and plan. If your debt load is unmanageable, ask a local attorney about your options, including legal protections available in your region.

If the debt isn’t yours (or the numbers are wrong)

Signs it might be an error

• The creditor is unfamiliar.

• The amount is off, or the dates don’t match.

• You already paid or settled.

• You were a victim of identity theft.

• The debt belongs to someone with a similar name.

What to do

1. Dispute in writing right away. Ask for validation and copies of key documents (like the original agreement and payment history).

2. Attach proof, if you have it bank statements, prior settlement letters, police report for identity theft, or any correspondence.

3. Check your credit reports (if available in your country). Dispute any incorrect entries through the bureaus as well.

4. Freeze or lock your credit if identity theft is suspected.

5. Keep calm and document everything. Errors are common. Organized people win these disputes.

Dispute letter (template)

[Your Name]  
[Your Address]  
[City, State/Province, Postal Code]  
[Email] [Phone]

[Date]

[Collector’s Name]  
[Company]  
[Address]

Re: Dispute & Validation Request

I dispute the debt you claim I owe. Please provide validation, including:
- The name and address of the original creditor,
- The amount owed with an itemized breakdown,
- Documentation showing I am responsible for this debt.

Until you provide verification, stop collection efforts. If you report this debt to any credit bureau, mark it as “disputed.”

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

Keep records like a pro (this pays off)

Create a simple folder (digital is fine). Save:

• All letters and emails (PDFs, photos of envelopes, screenshots).

• Call logs: date, time, number, who you spoke to, what they said.

• Voicemails and texts.

• Copies of anything you send (letters, faxes, emails) and proof of delivery.

• Settlement letters and receipts.

Call log template (columns): Date | Time | Collector Name | Company | Phone/Channel | Summary of Call | Next Step | Your Initials

Good records turn “he said, she said” into facts. That’s powerful.

Credit reporting and collection accounts

What to expect

• Collection accounts can hurt your credit scores. The impact tends to fade over time, but it’s sharp at the beginning.

• Paying or settling a collection may or may not remove it right away. Policies vary by country, bureau, and creditor.

• Some collectors will agree to update how the account is reported after payment. Get this agreement in writing before you pay.

Pay-for-delete? Proceed carefully

“Pay-for-delete” means you pay, and the collector asks the bureau to remove the entry. In many places, this is discouraged or limited, but some collectors will still agree. If you try this approach:

• Ask for a written letter on company letterhead stating they will request deletion upon payment.

• Understand that deletion isn’t always guaranteed.

• Keep proof of everything.

Disputing incorrect reporting

If a collection account is wrong, dispute it with the credit bureau(s) and the collector. Provide evidence. Keep copies of your disputes and the bureau responses.

When to get help

• You’re served with a lawsuit. Get legal advice immediately.

• You’re dealing with identity theft. You may need guidance to clear your records.

• Large or complex debts. A consumer lawyer or qualified advisor can save you from costly mistakes.

• Harassment or clear violations. Professionals can help you document and pursue claims.

• You’re overwhelmed. A nonprofit credit counselor can help you build a plan you can actually stick to.

Ask specifically for “consumer law” or “debt defense” experience. If money is tight, search for legal aid or clinics in your area.

FAQs

How do I stop the calls?
Tell the collector, preferably in writing, to stop contacting you by phone. Ask for all communication in writing. Block numbers and keep records. Use the cease-contact template above.

Can they sue me?
Yes, but they need to prove their case and file within the legal time limit. If you’re served, respond by the deadline and get advice.

Can they call my family or boss?
They can’t discuss your debt with others. They may contact someone just to find you, but not to disclose details or harass.

Can they call at night or very early?
No. There are restricted hours. If calls come at unreasonable times, document it.

Can they text or email me?
Yes, but the same rules apply: no harassment, no lies, and they must identify themselves. You can tell them to stop.

How many times can they call?
They can’t call repeatedly to annoy or harass. If you’re getting constant calls, note the dates and times and put your stop-calling request in writing.

Can they threaten to arrest me?
No. Debt is a civil issue, not a criminal one. Threats of arrest are illegal.

Can they add more fees and interest?
Only if your original agreement or local law allows it. Ask for an itemized breakdown.

Can they garnish my wages without a court order?
In most places, they need a court judgment first. There are exceptions and limits; check local law.

Will paying restart the statute of limitations?
In some regions, yes. Even a small payment or written promise can restart the clock. Know the rules where you live before paying on an old debt.

Should I record calls?
Only if it’s legal where you live. Some places require consent from the other party. If in doubt, don’t record; keep detailed written notes instead.

What if the debt is sold to another collector?
The new collector must follow the same rules. Ask for a fresh validation notice and keep your records going.

Templates you can copy

1) Cease-contact (short version)

Subject: Cease Contact

To [Collector],

Stop contacting me by phone, text, or social media. Communicate only in writing to [your address or email].

[Your Name]

2) Validation request + dispute (robust)

Subject: Dispute & Validation Request

To [Collector],

I dispute the debt you claim I owe. Please provide validation (original creditor, amount, itemized statement, and documentation showing I’m responsible). Pause collection until you provide verification. If you report this debt to any credit bureau, mark it “disputed.”

[Your Name]
[Mailing Address]

3) Settlement request (only after verification)

Subject: Settlement Proposal

To [Collector],

Subject to validation of the debt, I can offer [amount or %] as a lump-sum settlement on account [last 4 digits/account ID], on the condition that:

- You accept the payment as full satisfaction of the account,
- You will not sell any remaining balance,
- You will update any credit reporting to reflect the account as paid/settled,
- You will send a signed settlement letter before I pay.

Please confirm in writing.

[Your Name]

A simple action plan (checklist)

1. Collect info: Name of collector, company, contact details, account number.

2. Get it in writing: If you don’t have a validation notice, request one.

3. Decide your boundary: Calls stressing you out? Say “No phone calls. Writing only.”

4. Dispute if needed: If anything is off, send a dispute and validation request.

5. Document: Keep a call log, save voicemails, and screenshot texts.

6. Know the clock: Look up your local statute of limitations before paying.

7. Negotiate carefully: Never pay without a written agreement.

8. Protect your accounts: Don’t give direct bank access; use safer payment methods.

9. If sued: Don’t panic. Read the papers, note the deadline, respond, and get help.

10. Follow through: File your letters, store receipts, and update your log.

A quick story (because this happens a lot)

Tina kept getting calls about a card she closed years ago. The balance didn’t look right, and the caller got aggressive. She stopped the calls with one sentence: “Put it in writing.” Then she sent a short dispute letter. The collector went quiet for three weeks and finally sent paperwork—turns out the amount included fees that weren’t allowed. She settled for less than half with a written agreement and slept better the same night. No drama. Just steps.

Final thoughts

You don’t have to be a lawyer to stand up for yourself. Know your rights. Keep everything in writing. Make the collector follow the rules.

If you need help, reach out to a consumer lawyer, legal aid, or a trusted nonprofit credit counselor in your area.

Have a question I didn’t cover? Drop it below. If you want, I can turn the templates here into downloadable letters with your details filled in.